Date night makeup

I went for the subtler,more natural look but now that I'm looking at these photos I think I like the heavy liner look better...what do you think? Which one would you choose for a  first date? I think men don't like heavy makeup at all,but we,girls,on the other hand find it lovely,don't we?at least I do! Any personal experiences on the subject you want to share? please do! xoxoxo
Products used - Mac, The BodyShop, Estee Lauder, Avon
Brushes - Mac

ps. most of my pics from the first look were blurry for some reason or with a blueish hue, so I only used one! please don't hold it against me! :)